Could be a to high of a ev value?
The first one is at 6, the second at 16 + a bit of light compensation.
Maybe upload your test file. 😉
I tried to upload a file - clicked on the paperclip icon for insert file and I get this:
"Your attachment must be one of: gif,png,jpg,jpeg,zip,tar.gz,pdf,txt,ass"
Can you zip up the file or upload it somewhere else and post the link here?
Can you post your shader settings for the plane? Is the Specular Ray Depth high enough?
I changed the Specular Ray Depth to 16 and it made no difference. I would like to send my sample file if I could.
It looks like its something to do with the Exposure (and Physical camera) control you are using. I also noticed you are using a Physical Sun & Sky Environment. I replaced it with Arnolds Physical Sky and it seems to behave correctly.